Forming American Politics : Ideals, Interests, and Institutions in Colonial New York and Pennsylvania

Alan Tully offers a comparative study of colonial political life and a rethinking of the foundations of American political culture.

He chooses for his comparison the two colonies that arguably had the most profound impact on American political history - New York and Pennsylvania, the rich and varied colonies at the geographical and ideological centre of British colonial America.

Tully's fundamental argument that out of Anglo-American influences and the cumulative character of each colonial experience, New York and Pennsylvania developed their own distinctive but complementary characteristics.

In making this case, he enters the prominent argument between the "classical Republican" and "liberal" views of early American public thought.

He contends that the radical Whig element of classical Republicanism was far less influential than historians have believed and that the political experience of New York and Pennsylvania led to their role as innovators of liberal political concepts and discourse. In a conclusion that pursues his insights into the revolutionary and early Republican years, Tully underlines a paradox in American political development: not only were the pathbreaking liberal politicians of New York and Pennsylvania the least inclined towards revolutionary fervour, but their political language and concepts (integral to an emerging liberal democratic order) were rooted in oligarchical political practice.